Fiduciary duty and litigation

Who is an ERISA fiduciary for a health and welfare plan?

Originally posted by

Who is an ERISA fiduciary for health and welfare plans?

Under ERISA, anyone who exercises discretionary authority over a health and welfare plan—or its assets—must act solely in the best interest of plan participants and beneficiaries.

ERISA fiduciaries in health and welfare plans include:

• Plan sponsors or committees that make decisions about plan coverage or benefit design

• Claims administrators or third-party administrators (TPAs) with discretionary authority to approve or deny benefits

• Trustees or plan administrators responsible for managing plan operations and ensuring compliance

But, not everyone involved in administering health and welfare benefits is a fiduciary.

Non-fiduciaries could include:

• TPAs that perform purely administrative tasks without discretionary decision-making

• Service providers (e.g., recordkeepers or brokers) offering basic data or transactional support

• Consultants providing general education or recommendations without authority to implement their decisions.

The bottom line: ERISA fiduciaries must uphold a high standard of care and loyalty—always putting participants’ interests first.

If you manage or oversee a health and welfare plan, it’s essential to understand whether you’re acting as a fiduciary.

What’s your biggest challenge in navigating ERISA compliance for health and welfare plans?

Originally posted on LinkedIn, where the discussion and source links live in the comments.

About the author

Chris Vanderwolk is Director of Compliance and Innovation at OneDigital | Kistler Tiffany Benefits General Agency, where he helps brokers and employers navigate the regulatory complexity of employee benefits. An ERISA attorney with more than 19 years in the benefits industry, he specializes in translating what the law actually requires into language people can use.

All writing